Smith. Shapps. Now Cameron lies to Parliament on NHS stats


I’ve written recently about the gross abuse of statistics by the DWP and by Grant Shapps on behalf of the government, which led to public rebukes by Andrew Dilnot, the Chair of the UK Statistics Authority.

This is not aberrant behaviour. The Tory party has a strong track record of statistical distortion and even outright lies. David Cameron lied to Parliament last year about new private sector jobs created under his government (an offence that used to lead to automatic resignation if discovered). Last week, he was at it again.

During PMQs on Wednesday, during a typically woeful and arrogant performance in which he barely referred to an opposition question let alone answer one, Cameron was challenged by a Labour MP on the massive increase in A&E waiting times. Here’s the exchange:

Robert Flello (Stoke-on-Trent South) (Lab): Yet again we have no answers from the Prime Minister, who blames everyone but himself and denies that there is a crisis in A and E. Let me give him one more chance to try to give an answer. Why does he not admit what everyone in the health service knows—his £3 billion reorganisation has diverted attention and resources from patient care and he has betrayed his promises? May we now have an answer?
The Prime Minister: The abolition of the bureaucracy that this Government have brought about will put billions of pounds extra into the NHS, but the point that the hon. Gentleman has to take on is that this Government made a decision, which was not to cut the NHS. We are putting £12.7 billion extra into the NHS.

£12.7 billion extra into the NHS. David Cameron knows this to be untrue. He knows it because, like his ministers Iain (Duncan) Smith and Grant Shapps, he and his government were rebuked late last year for making similar false claims on NHS spending. Here’s how Sky News reported it:

he [Dilnot] said the UKSA‘s calculations were based on what he considered “the most authoritative source” of national statistics on the subject – the Treasury’s Public Spending Statistics publication.

On the basis of these figures, we would conclude that expenditure on the NHS in real terms was lower in 2011-12 than it was in 2009-10,” he said.

Even the Telegraph, normally a tame Rottweiler for the Tories when it comes to the NHS, got saw the reality of the matter and got in on the act with this headline:


When the £12 billion claim first reared its head, it was challenged robustly by BBC Politics Show host Andrew Neil. Interviewed after his speech to the Conservative party conference last autumn, Jeremy Hunt tried to claim that the Tories had put this extra money into the NHS.

Neil, to his credit, shot back that this was “pure propaganda” – and revealed that the funding increase was £60 millionfar less than matching inflation, and therefore a substantial real-terms decrease.

But the truth about NHS spending under this government doesn’t end there. A huge amount of the money that the coalition puts into the NHS simply goes in the front door and straight out the back. As I reported last year, in the 2011/12 fiscal year, the Treasury ‘clawed back’ no less than £1.4 billion from NHS funds, while siphoning off another £1.5bn for other uses – dwarfing the paltry increase in budgeted funds.

But it gets worse. The clawback for the 2012/13 year was even higher – at £2.2 billion.

The reality of the NHS funding situation is no secret, and is certainly not something that Cameron could claim to be in ignorance of or that it slipped his mind.

No matter which way you cut it, Cameron – knowingly – lied to the House and should resign immediately, were it not that such things are more likely to lead to promotion than to resignation under this government, as Jeremy Hunt’s case showed last year. Not only that, but he repeated a lie that he’s already been rebuked about and told not to repeat.

I have therefore written to Andrew Dilnot at the UKSA as follows (with a copy to Shadow Health Secretary Andy Burnham):

Dear Mr Dilnot,

Last Wednesday (5 June), David Cameron claimed during Prime Minister’s Questions:
“We are putting £12.7 billion extra into the NHS.”
Looking at Treasury spending statistics, I see a nominal, but not real-terms, increase in NHS spending compared to the last year under the previous government, but certainly nothing like £12.7 billion. Since the Treasury routinely claws back well billions from the NHS – some £2.2 billion during 2012/13, up from £1.5bn in 2011/12 – Mr Cameron’s statement was a bald lie. He did not say that NHS budgets had increased, but that more was “put into” the NHS – which is not true when the Treasury is clawing back far more than the nominal increase.
And even if this were not the case, budgets have not risen by £12.7 billion – or at all in real terms according to yourself late last year.
Since you have been so good as to rebuke the government over false statistical claims on at least a couple of occasions this year, please would you take a look at this matter and do so again?
See the following links for further information:
I look forward to your response.
Best regards,
Steve Walker

Can I ask you to do the same, to make sure that this issue receives the attention – and eventually the public rebuke – that it deserves? If you want to send your own complaint to the UKSA, the email address is

Can I ask you to do the same, to make sure that this issue receives the attention – and eventually the public rebuke – that it deserves? If you want to send your own complaint to the UKSA, the email address is

You might want to copy it to your MP, too – a complaint from Sheila Gilmore MP to Andrew Dilnot led to the rebuke on ESA benefit lies, so some MPs do pay attention to such things and take action. If you want to find your MPs details, you can look them up very quickly at

Jump in and let’s turn up the heat on Walter Mitty David Cameron for his persistent, arrogant lies!

27 responses to “Smith. Shapps. Now Cameron lies to Parliament on NHS stats

  1. Reblogged this on Vox Political and commented:
    I’m grateful to Steve at Skwawkbox for relieving me of some of the pressure from the multitude of article-worthy material currently flinging itself towards Vox Political with gay, “It’s Summer!”, abandon. I was going to write an article (or part of one) about the revelation that Grant Shapps tried to get officials in the Department for Communities and Local Government to cover up emails that showed he had misled Parliament. The story is here:
    So that’s Cameron, LieDS, Shapps (if that’s what he’s calling himself today), Jeremy Misprint Hunt – all guilty of lying to Parliament, which is contempt of Parliament, as revealed on Voc Political a few weeks ago. Perhaps, besides writing to the UKSA, we should write to the Speaker and the Standards Committee and ask why they’re turning a blind eye to it.

  2. Honesty is the best policy, but insanity is a better defence.
    “In a time of universal deceit – telling the truth is a revolutionary act.”
George Orwell

  3. Pingback: Smith. Shapps. Now Cameron lies to Parliament o...·

  4. Well said Steve! No wonder that the Public have no faith in Politics when our so called leaders can huff, puff and bluff their way through life, scattering outright lies and utter deceptions on their travels like confetti in a hurricane. Lions led by the donkeys in the deceitful Coalition Circus of Clowns and Incompetents. Charles

  5. It is also often said or implied that the NHS is somehow exempt from “austerity” which is impacting on other government departments. Given demography and advances (which may be good for, or save society money but cost in the NHS budget) it is said that inflation + 4% keeps the NHS afloat (more if you want to invest). If the actual spend is less than inflation and subject to additional clawback then the “pain” for the NHS (and it’s staff) may be 6% per year in terms of what can now be offered, or call it 3% if we all manage a 3% CIP (Cost Improvement Programme – increasingly difficult). Compound that for 5 years and it’s about 20% – entirely in keeping with the £20 bn (of a £100 bn budget) “Nicholson Challenge” – the challenge being “can you chaps do the expected increase in health activity for 20% less than you had before?”.
    Well we’ll all do our best, even though we’re in a torrent of “creative destruction” but please don’t insult me by suggesting that we are somehow not in the same boat as all the other public services (while trying to heavily imply to patients that we’re not) and indeed the private sector (where applicable in the economy). It feels like cuts because it is cuts.

  6. I can hardly believe it but David Cameron has just repeated his claim that the Coalition are ‘putting £12.7 billion EXTRA into the NHS’ not once but twice, during today’s Prime Minister’s Questions!!
    He also claimed that £3.6 million of that was going to NW London hospitals.
    I’m still waiting for a reply from my MP (Labour) and Andrew Dilnot, although the UKSA have at least acknowledged that they’ve received
    my email. Lets hope Mr Dilnot does something about this soon.

  7. Pingback: Cameron repeats his NHS £12.7bn lie in PMQs. Twice. Help shut him down. | The SKWAWKBOX Blog·

  8. Pingback: REFORM: The ‘independent’ Think Tank that wants us to think its a charity that drives the thinking behind NHS privatisation – backed by over THIRTY multinational corporations. | Grannie's Last Mix·

  9. Pingback: REFORM: The ‘independent’ Think Tank that wants us to think its a charity·

  10. Pingback: Impending Chaos at Private Hospitals? A First Glimpse of One Possible Effect of Monitor’s Regulation’s | Grannie's Last Mix·

  11. Reblogged this on The SKWAWKBOX Blog and commented:

    In the run-up to the General Election, Cameron and co have been repeatedly claiming that they put more money into the NHS every year they have been in government.

    It is a bare-faced lie – and one they were publicly spanked for by the UK Statistics Authority when they were in government, as even the Daily Torygraph reported.

    But that won’t stop them claiming it in a desperate attempt to nullify Labour’s justified position as the creators and defenders of the NHS.

    Please share widely to counteract the lie – and this post, too:

  12. Did Shapps Grant Boris a wish too?

    Is Grant Shapps just the fall guy to distract us while the desperate Tories quietly use ‘Michael Green’ to implement a widespread editing whitewash across Wikipedia before the election..?!

    For example, isn’t it rather hard to believe that the Boris Johnson entry would suddenly ‘benefit’ from over 120 changes during April? Are they all likely just to be innocuous editorial “tidying up” changes, pre-May?

    A copy of the Boris entry was made on the morning of 14th April here:
    (links straight to the now-missing ‘Ancestry’ section)

    It included, for example, an ‘Ancestry’ section containing the family tree, with Turkish family links etc.

    The pre-election entry for Boris has 17 previous sections missing, including his ‘Ancestry’:

    3.4 Ban on use of alcohol on public transport
    3.6 2008 Olympics
    3.7 2012 Olympics
    3.8 US presidential election
    3.9 Resignation of Ian Blair
    3.10 Expenses controversy
    3.15 24-hour Tube
    7 Controversies
    7.1 Alleged theft of cigar case
    7.2 Damian Green arrest
    7.3 “Chicken feed” remark
    7.4 Veronica Wadley
    7.5 Helen Macintyre
    7.6 St Patrick’s Day celebrations
    7.7 Remarks about women in Malaysian universities
    8 Charitable activity
    10 Ancestry

    Are we becoming paranoid about Tory lies – or just too used to them all?

  13. World-record late comment in relation to the last line of ideb8.

    I have noticed a tendency amongst higher management (pay > 140k say) and politicians to lie so frequently that you wonder whether they simply don’t realise they’re doing it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s